Made fresh daily. We fry them up and decorate them to order. You can pre-order or bring the family in and watch us decorate them right before your eyes. The best seller? Dirt and worms! Chocolate icing dipped in crushed chocolate cookie crumbs with 2 gummi worms on top!
.75 each, $3.75/6, $7/12
Powdered sugar, Cinnamon Sugar or Plain.
$1 each, $4.50/6, $9/12
Chocolate, Vanilla or Maple.
$1.25 each, $7/6, $12/12
Flavors: Reese’s Pieces, M&M’s, Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup, S’Mores, Sprinkles, Cotton Candy, Nerds, Butterfinger, Dirt and Worms, Maple Chocolate, Maple Pecan, Turtle, Samoa, Andes Mint, Peppermint.
Other Sweet Treats
Chocolate Covered Strawberries
Dipped in chocolate from Eiler’s Candy shop in downtown Dover. We use a semi-sweet chocolate which is the perfect balance between milk and dark. Available for pre-orders in 6 packs and by the dozen. Larger orders available when pre-ordered. We can also wrap a bow on them for no extra cost.
Chocolate Peanut Butter Buckeyes
$3.75/4, $5.25/6, $10/12
Handmade from scratch and dipped in chocolate from Eiler’s Candy Shop in downtown Dover. We use a semi-sweet chocolate which is the perfect balance between milk and dark. Available for walk-in or pre-orders in packs of 4, 6 or a dozen. Larger orders available when pre-ordered. We can also wrap a bow on them for no extra cost to make them the perfect gift for that foodie or OSU fan in your life!
Caramel Apples (Seasonal)
Big, beautiful Granny Smith apples dipped in our homemade caramel sauce. Available flavors: Original - $5.95 | Double Chocolate (dipped and drizzled in Eiler's chocolate) - $7.95 | Turtle (dipped in Eiler’s chocolate and coated in house toasted pecans) - $7.95.
Miss Heather makes amazing cookies but our ovens are usually full with pastries, cakes, cupcakes and cheesecakes. When there’s time, you’ll find a plate of her amazing cookies (Chocolate Chip, Oatmeal Cranberry, Pumpkin Spice, etc.) available at the front of our shop, but they’re not currently an item that we take orders for. We do have Mason Jar Mixes available year round so that you can make delicious cookies (and memories) at home.
Need cookies for an event? We suggest some of our friends:
Dover/New Phila Area
Royally Iced Designs-The name says it all. Amazing royal icing decorations that rival the best that you’ll find on Pinterest or Instagram from this local home baker.
Canton Area Little Chunk of Goodness- She does it all!