Visit Us
- 113 W. 3rd St., Dover, OH 44622
- Hours: Tue-Fri (7am-5pm), Sat (7am-2pm), Sun & Mon (Closed)
- 330.343.5434
- info@sugarfuse.com
Cake Menu
We can craft custom cakes or make a signature cake from the selection at the bottom of the page.
Custom Cakes
Let’s create something perfect, just for you. Birthdays, showers, graduations — they’re all better with a Sugarfuse! custom cake.
Pricing: Due to the uniqueness of custom cakes, each cake is priced individually, but we’ve provided some “starting at” prices. The final price depends on all design aspects. Contact us for a quote.
Smash Cakes
Jumbo Cupcake
From $5A jumbo cupcake in a cupcake liner. See list for flavor options.
4" Cake
From $206" Cake
From $35Party Cakes
6" Cake
From $35Serves (10-12).
8" Cake
From $45Serves about (20).
10" Cake
From $55Serves about (30).
Two-Tier Cake
From $756" cake on top of 8" cake. Serves about (30).
Cake Flavors: Signature Chocolate, Vanilla Bean, White Wedding (Almond), Red Velvet, Marble, 1/2 & 1/2 Chocolate & Vanilla, Pineapple.
Fillings: Any of the buttercreams and cheese cream icings listed below can be used as filling. We also have fruit fillings: Raspberry, Strawberry, Lemon and Blueberry.
Buttercream Flavors: Vanilla Bean, Chocolate Fudge, Peanut Butter, Strawberry, Blueberry, Lemon, Raspberry, Mocha, Salted Caramel, Root Beer, Key Lime, Peppermint.
Other Icings: Cream Cheese, Cinnamon Cream Cheese, Whipped Cream (can be flavored, Ho Ho filling.
Signature Cakes
Our 6″ cakes serve (10-12) and 8″ serves (18-20).
Chocolate Peanut Butter
$35/$45Our best seller.
On the inside, 4 layers of our award winning made from scratch chocolate cake, 2 layers of chocolate silk buttercream, peanut butter buttercream in the middle. On the outside, more pb buttercream, a cage made with chocolate from Eiler’s Candy Shop, and topped with chopped Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups and drizzled with more chocolate.
On the inside, 4 layers of our award winning made from scratch chocolate cake, 2 layers of chocolate silk buttercream, peanut butter buttercream in the middle. On the outside, more pb buttercream, a cage made with chocolate from Eiler’s Candy Shop, and topped with chopped Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups and drizzled with more chocolate.
Chocolate Caramel Turtle
$35/$45Judge’s Choice Award at Chocolate Love A’fair (Judged on taste and appearance).
On the inside, 4 layers of our made from scratch chocolate cake, 2 layers of chocolate silk buttercream, and salted caramel buttercream in the middle. On the outside, more salted caramel buttercream, a cage made with chocolate from Eiler’s Candy Shop, and topped with house toasted pecans, and drizzled with caramel and more chocolate.
On the inside, 4 layers of our made from scratch chocolate cake, 2 layers of chocolate silk buttercream, and salted caramel buttercream in the middle. On the outside, more salted caramel buttercream, a cage made with chocolate from Eiler’s Candy Shop, and topped with house toasted pecans, and drizzled with caramel and more chocolate.
Southern Red Velvet
$35/$45A soft, moist, buttery classic.
Our family recipe is an amazing made from scratch Southern Red Velvet cake. We stack it 4 layers high with 3 layers of cream cheese icing on the inside and all around the cake. We add a little texture to the outside icing to make this cake even more beautiful.
Our family recipe is an amazing made from scratch Southern Red Velvet cake. We stack it 4 layers high with 3 layers of cream cheese icing on the inside and all around the cake. We add a little texture to the outside icing to make this cake even more beautiful.
Chocolate Covered Strawberry Cake
$40/$47This one has become a tradition with some of our long time customers.
On the inside, 4 layers of our chocolate cake, 2 layers of chocolate silk buttercream, and strawberry buttercream in the middle. On the outside, more strawberry buttercream, a cage made with chocolate from Eiler’s Candy Shop, and topped with juicy, delicious strawberries dipped in more Eiler’s chocolate. We use a semi-sweet that is the perfect balance between milk and dark.
On the inside, 4 layers of our chocolate cake, 2 layers of chocolate silk buttercream, and strawberry buttercream in the middle. On the outside, more strawberry buttercream, a cage made with chocolate from Eiler’s Candy Shop, and topped with juicy, delicious strawberries dipped in more Eiler’s chocolate. We use a semi-sweet that is the perfect balance between milk and dark.
Chocolate Covered Strawberry Ganche Cake
$30/$40Less icing, but more chocolate.
A “naked” cake. 4 layers of chocolate cake with strawberry buttercream filling and a luxurious chocolate ganache poured over the top and dripping down the sides. Our ganache is made with Eiler’s chocolate and heavy cream. We top it off with our chocolate covered strawberries.
A “naked” cake. 4 layers of chocolate cake with strawberry buttercream filling and a luxurious chocolate ganache poured over the top and dripping down the sides. Our ganache is made with Eiler’s chocolate and heavy cream. We top it off with our chocolate covered strawberries.
Chocolate Raspberry Cake
$40/$47Judge's Choice Award at Chocolate Love A'fair (Judged on taste and appearance).
On the inside, 3 layers of our chocolate cake, a layer of chocolate silk buttercream, and a luxurious layer of fresh raspberries and whipped cream. On the outside, raspberry buttercream, a cage made with chocolate from Eiler's Candy Shop, and topped with more berries and whipped cream plus chocolate curls.
On the inside, 3 layers of our chocolate cake, a layer of chocolate silk buttercream, and a luxurious layer of fresh raspberries and whipped cream. On the outside, raspberry buttercream, a cage made with chocolate from Eiler's Candy Shop, and topped with more berries and whipped cream plus chocolate curls.
Vanilla Almond
$35/$45There’s more to life than chocolate.
On the inside, 4 layers of almond cake, 3 layers of vanilla bean spiked vanilla buttercream. On the outside, vanilla bean buttercream. We can also add other fillings like: Strawberry, Raspberry, Blueberry, Lemon, Salted Caramel, Ho Ho and more.
On the inside, 4 layers of almond cake, 3 layers of vanilla bean spiked vanilla buttercream. On the outside, vanilla bean buttercream. We can also add other fillings like: Strawberry, Raspberry, Blueberry, Lemon, Salted Caramel, Ho Ho and more.
Ho Ho
$27/$37Our twist on a classic.
4 layers of chocolate cake sandwiching 3 layers of ho ho cream filling and our luxurious chocolate ganache poured over the top and dripping down the sides.
4 layers of chocolate cake sandwiching 3 layers of ho ho cream filling and our luxurious chocolate ganache poured over the top and dripping down the sides.
Chocolate Bacon Pecan
$40/$47Judge’s Choice Award Winner at Chocolate Love A’fair (Judged on taste and appearance).
On the inside, 4 layers of our chocolate cake, 2 layers of chocolate silk buttercream, and salted caramel buttercream in the middle along with a layer of our candied bacon/pecan mixture. On the outside, chocolate silk buttercream and a cage made with chocolate from Eiler’s Candy Shop.
On the inside, 4 layers of our chocolate cake, 2 layers of chocolate silk buttercream, and salted caramel buttercream in the middle along with a layer of our candied bacon/pecan mixture. On the outside, chocolate silk buttercream and a cage made with chocolate from Eiler’s Candy Shop.
Death By Chocolate
$40/$47Over the top bliss...in cake form.
On the inside, 4 layers of our chocolate cake, 2 layers of dark chocolate buttercream, and chocolate silk buttercream in the middle. On the outside, chocolate silk buttercream, dripped chocolate ganache, and the top is adorned with various chocolate delicacies like a macaron, crisp pearls, shards of chocolate, etc.
On the inside, 4 layers of our chocolate cake, 2 layers of dark chocolate buttercream, and chocolate silk buttercream in the middle. On the outside, chocolate silk buttercream, dripped chocolate ganache, and the top is adorned with various chocolate delicacies like a macaron, crisp pearls, shards of chocolate, etc.